Author Archive

City Of Boston Ordered To Pay Police Union Members $16.5 Million To Resolve Longstanding Labor Dispute.

Monday, August 23rd, 2010 by John Becker

It is a case that began way back in September 1994, when the City of Boston (“City”) first assigned Boston Municipal Police (“Municipal Police”) to patrol the Boston Housing Authority (“BHA”) housing developments without first bargaining with the Boston Police…

Supreme Judicial Court Upholds Arbitrator’s Decision, Orders Lynn to Pay Union

Wednesday, January 6th, 2010 by John Becker

In a unanimous decision issued January 6, 2010, the state’s highest court has ruled in favor of the Lynn Police Association, MCOP Local 302 (“union”) in a contractual dispute with the City of Lynn (“City”). As a result of the ruling,…

Civil Service Commission Clarifies Firefighter Seniority Rules For Layoffs

Tuesday, August 11th, 2009 by John Becker

The Civil Service Commission issued a decision on August 6, 2009 that allows employers to count some prior non-fire service in calculating firefighter seniority in the event of a layoff.  The decision confirms two prior Commission decisions from the 1990s,…

SJC Gives Public Employers New Tool For Blocking Disability Retirements

Tuesday, May 19th, 2009 by John Becker

In a recent decision, the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court has allowed a public employer to block an injured employee’s attempt to retire on disability by modifying his work duties so that they no longer resemble his original core job duties. …

Appeals Court: Municipal Finance Laws Do Not Permit Cities And Towns To Breach Union Contracts; City Of Lynn Ordered To Pay $300,000 To Mcop Local

Monday, January 12th, 2009 by John Becker

The Massachusetts Appeals Court ruled on January 9, 2009 that the City of Lynn must pay nearly $300,000 in damages to the Lynn Police Association, Massachusetts Coalition of Police Local 302, for violating a memorandum of agreement.  In so ruling,…

Civil Service Commission Bars City From Filling Fire Lieutenant Vacancy To Save Room For Returning Disability Retirees

Saturday, August 2nd, 2008 by John Becker

In a surprisingly anti-employer decision, the Civil Service Commission enforced a preference for formerly disabled retirees at the expense of existing employees ready, willing and able to immediately accept a promotion appointment. In Faggiano, Jones & Cappuccio v. City of…

In Sjc’s Latest Assault On Labor Arbitration, Public Employees Lose Even When They Win

Wednesday, July 2nd, 2008 by John Becker

At first glance, the Supreme Judicial Court’s decision in Sheriff of Suffolk County v. Jail Officers and Employees (http://socialaw.org/slip.htm?cid=18288&sid=120, decided June 23, 2008), which upholds an arbitrator’s reinstatement of a public employee, is unremarkable. Unfortunately, the Court’s reasoning and commentary in…

Appeals Court Withholds Civil Service Rights From Returning Disability Retiree, Saying Retraining Is Prerequisite For Tenure

Monday, April 7th, 2008 by John Becker

A recent Appeals Court decision gives employers another tool in keeping public employees from returning to work after disability retirement. In Facella v. City of Newton, 69 Mass. App. Ct. 459 (2007), the Court denied civil service rights to a…